Provided by: po4a_0.41-1ubuntu1_all bug


       Locale::Po4a::Sgml - convert SGML documents from/to PO files


       The po4a (PO for anything) project goal is to ease translations (and more interestingly,
       the maintenance of translations) using gettext tools on areas where they were not expected
       like documentation.

       Locale::Po4a::Sgml is a module to help the translation of documentation in the SGML format
       into other [human] languages.

       This module uses nsgmls to parse the SGML files. Make sure it is installed.  Also make
       sure that the DTD of the SGML files are installed in the system.


           Space separated list of keywords indicating which part you want to debug. Possible
           values are: tag, generic, entities and refs.

           Give more information about what's going on.

           Space separated list of extra tags (beside the DTD provided ones) whose content should
           form an extra msgid.

           Space separated list of extra tags (beside the DTD provided ones) containing other
           tags, some of them being of category translate.

           Space separated list of tags which increase the indentation level.

           The layout within those tags should not be changed. The paragraph won't get wrapped,
           and no extra indentation space or new line will be added for cosmetic purpose.

           Tags not needing to be closed.

           Tags ignored and considered as plain char data by po4a. That is to say that they can
           be part of an msgid. For example, <b> is a good candidate for this category since
           putting it in the translate section would create msgids not being whole sentences,
           which is bad.

           A space separated list of attributes that need to be translated. You can specify the
           attributes by their name (for example, "lang"), but you can also prefix it with a tag
           hierarchy, to specify that this attribute will only be translated when it is into the
           specified tag. For example: <bbb><aaa>lang specifies that the lang attribute will only
           be translated if it is in an <aaa> tag, which is in a <bbb> tag.  The tag names are
           actually regular expressions so you can also write things like <aaa|bbbb>lang to only
           translate lang attributes that are in an <aaa> or a <bbb> tag.

           A space separated list of attributes for which the translation must be qualified by
           the attribute name. Note that this setting automatically adds the given attribute into
           the 'attributes' list too.

           Proceed even if the DTD is unknown or if nsgmls finds errors in the input file.

           By default, msgids containing only one entity (like '&version;') are skipped for the
           translator comfort. Activating this option prevents this optimisation. It can be
           useful if the document contains a construction like "<title>&Aacute;</title>", even if
           I doubt such things to ever happen...

           Space separated list of entities that won't be inlined.  Use this option with caution:
           it may cause nsgmls (used internally) to add tags and render the output document


       The result is perfect. I.e., the generated documents are exactly the same. But there are
       still some problems:

       · The error output of nsgmls is redirected to /dev/null, which is clearly bad. I don't
         know how to avoid that.

         The problem is that I have to "protect" the conditional inclusions (ie, the "<! [ %foo
         [" and "]]>" stuff) from nsgmls. Otherwise nsgmls eats them, and I don't know how to
         restore them in the final document. To prevent that, I rewrite them to "{PO4A-beg-foo}"
         and "{PO4A-end}".

         The problem with this is that the "{PO4A-end}" and such I add are valid in the document
         (not in a <p> tag or so).

         Everything works well with nsgmls's output redirected that way, but it will prevent us
         from detecting that the document is badly formatted.

       · It does work only with the DebianDoc and DocBook DTD. Adding support for a new DTD
         should be very easy. The mechanism is the same for every DTD, you just have to give a
         list of the existing tags and some of their characteristics.

         I agree, this needs some more documentation, but it is still considered as beta, and I
         hate to document stuff which may/will change.

       · Warning, support for DTDs is quite experimental. I did not read any reference manual to
         find the definition of every tag. I did add tag definition to the module 'till it works
         for some documents I found on the net. If your document use more tags than mine, it
         won't work. But as I said above, fixing that should be quite easy.

         I did test DocBook against the SAG (System Administrator Guide) only, but this document
         is quite big, and should use most of the DocBook specificities.

         For DebianDoc, I tested some of the manuals from the DDP, but not all yet.

       · In case of file inclusion, string reference of messages in PO files (ie, lines like "#:
         en/titletoc.sgml:9460") will be wrong.

         This is because I preprocess the file to protect the conditional inclusion (ie, the "<!
         [ %foo [" and "]]>" stuff) and some entities (like &version;) from nsgmls because I want
         them verbatim to the generated document. For that, I make a temp copy of the input file
         and do all the changes I want to this before passing it to nsgmls for parsing.

         So that it works, I replace the entities asking for a file inclusion by the content of
         the given file (so that I can protect what needs to in subfile also). But nothing is
         done so far to correct the references (i.e., filename and line number) afterward. I'm
         not sure what the best thing to do is.


       This module is an adapted version of sgmlspl (SGML postprocessor for the SGMLS and NSGMLS
       parsers) which was:

        Copyright (c) 1995 by David Megginson <>

       The adaptation for po4a was done by:

        Denis Barbier <>
        Martin Quinson (


        Copyright (c) 1995 by David Megginson <>
        Copyright 2002, 2003, 2004, 2005 by SPI, inc.

       This program is free software; you may redistribute it and/or modify it under the terms of
       GPL (see the COPYING file).